Does monitoring and evaluation improve joint management? The case of national parks in the NT

Does monitoring and evaluation improve joint management? The case of national parks in the NT

Project leadership

This project investigated whether monioring and evaluation with the participation of stakeholders including Indigenous Traditional owners enhances the benefits of joint management of parks and reserves in Australia. It determined the elements required to implement participatory monitoring and evaluation in a cost effective manner even in situations where stakeholders differ in views and power.

Projects in this theme

Current

Past

Joint management between traditional Indigenous owners of protected areas and the Northern Territory government is a legislative requirement. Substantial funds are invested in the process which can include employment of Indigenous rangers, the distribution of lease funds and agreements on cultural heritage. This project was a collaboration between CDU researchers, the parks service, the Northern and Central Land Councils and the traditional owners of four park clusters to monitor, in a participatory fashion, progress towards joint management. The traditional owners and park managers of Watarrka, Flora River, MacDonnell ranges and Adelaide River protected areas first identified indicators they thought appropriate for their parks. Most of these were concerned with process rather than outcomes, particularly related to human and social capital. Traditional owners in particular emphasised the need for respectful interaction, as might be expected as relationships are being established. They were also concerned that joint management yielded economic benefits including jobs <see Developing Indicators for Monitoring and Evaluating Joint Management Effectiveness in Protected Areas in the Northern Territory, Australia>.

Partners were also trained in participatory monitoring and undertook a baseline assessment. This suggested that natural resource condition, communication and use of traditional knowledge were mostly satisfactory. However it was agreed that training in park management and business as well as enterprise development were lacking <see Collaborative Measurement of Performance of Jointly Managed Protected Areas in Northern Australia>.

A guidebook was also produced on how participatory management should be undertaken was produced <see Guidebook for Supporting Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation of Jointly Managed Parks in the Northern Territory>. Importantly, if the monitoring occurs at the same time as annual planning meetings, the costs of participatory management are relatively low <see Costs of participatory monitoring and evaluation of joint management of protected areas in the Northern Territory, Australia> so that there is an opportunity to track change over time, particularly the impact of interventions.

RIEL researchers: Stephen Garnett, Natasha Stacey and Arturo Izurieta.

Year Type Citation
2009 Book Chapter Stacey, N. & Izurieta, A. V. RIMBA: Sustainable Forest Livelihoods in Malaysia and Australia 70 - 78 (Institute of Environment and Development (LESTARI), Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM), 2009). at <http://espace.cdu.edu.au/view/cdu:9010>
2011 Journal Article Izurieta, A. V. et al. Developing Indicators for Monitoring and Evaluating Joint Management Effectiveness in Protected Areas in the Northern Territory, Australia. Ecology and Society 16, (2011).
2011 Book Izurieta, A. V., Stacey, N. & Karam, J. Guidebook for Supporting Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation of Jointly Managed Parks in the Northern Territory. (Research Institute for the Environment and Livelihoods, Charles Darwin University, 2011).
2012 Journal Article Izurieta, A. V., Petheram, L., Stacey, N. & Garnett, S. T. Costs of participatory monitoring and evaluation of joint management of protected areas in the Northern Territory, Australia. Australasian Journal of Environmental Management 1 - 13 (2012). doi:10.1080/14486563.2012.726130
2013 Journal Article Stacey, N., Izurieta, A. V. & Garnett, S. T. Collaborative Measurement of Performance of Jointly Managed Protected Areas in Northern Australia. Ecology and Society 18, (2013).

Jump to NRBL themeJump to CMEM themeJump to FEM themeJump to SMWC themeJump to TRF themeJump to RIEL home

Innovative Research University

© 2011-2013 Charles Darwin University
Research Institute for the Environment and Livelihoods
Privacy Policy
CRICOS Provider No. 00300K | RTO Provider No. 0373

Phone (+61) 8 8946 6413
Email riel@cdu.edu.au